Economist special reports on financial crisis and information management

Saturday, March 13th, 2010

These days I am reading every other issue of Economist, those that contain special reports. A special report is a 10-15 page report that deals with a particular issue, for example financial crisis. It consists of a number of articles. Each article sheds light on a specific side of the topic, the articles are typically arranged in a logical order.

The financial crises special report explains the multiple reasons behind the troubles that world economy faced. It turns out that the underlying theory of risk evaluation was developed in mid-20th century. I noticed that Economist is always doing a good job on analyzing the history of a particular event. The underlying theories are always developed long time before their applications start to make a difference.

The use and misuse of computational models to evaluate the risk was the primary reason behind the crisis. A simple example of an error-prone model is when bank A owns shares of bank B and bank B owns shares of bank A. If one them collapses then the other will collapse too. But models often ignored this domino-effect. Of course, not everybody was that stupid. But the problem was that as soon as one bank began announcing higher yields other had to follow to stay competitive. Thus, the mathematicians were forced to bend their models to make them fit the desired higher yield.

Another article describes how the risk managers were treated. Various tricks were played to reduce their influence on the decision of borrowing money. One common trick was to work quietly on a proposal for weeks and show it to risk team only a couple of hours before the approval meeting so that they would not have time to evaluate it properly.

The rest of the report is devoted to how to avoid repetitions of the crisis. Of course, banks need to have bigger reverses in cash. Also they need to prepare themselves, they need to understand which factors lead to such crisis. They are playing board games now when a bank is put into a simulated crisis and the management needs to think how they got into such mess.

But regulators also need to do a lot. Too big to fail is one issue that they need to address. Another problem is that the Central Bank was kind enough to lend big amounts of money with low percentage which stimulated the desire of banks to borrow. If a bank has lots of money then it starts to attract kinds of customer it would typically not mess up with. It might even promise a higher yield than average but obviously such good life ends as soon as cheap money supply stops.

Another special report that I read deals with information deluge. Again, Economist begins with a history lesson: in 1917 a manufacturing manager complained on the effects of a telephone. It was called a big time-waster and confusion-generator. But Craig Mundie is saying that big data opens new horizons for new economies. Farecast, a system that Microsoft built allows to estimate when to buy a flight ticket depending on the expected change in the price.

Economist provides lots of examples how various companies saved using better information processing tools. For example Nestle found that nearly 9 million of its records were either obsolete or duplicate. Another example is Chinese company Li & Fung that operates a supply chain. One of the most important technologies is videoconferencing which allows buyers and manufacturers to examine the color of a material.

Another article is dedicated to Google. It managed to build a translation system using machine learning over a training set of 2 trillions words obtained through its book scanning technology. In early 1900s IBM tried to build a French-English program but their system did not work. The reason was that IBM had only millions documents, not billions. Therefore, big data generates big improvements. The magazine also mentions the Data Liberation Front – an attitude Google is taking towards users’ data.

Next article is describing open government. On his first day in the office, Barack Obama issued a presidential memorandum ordering federal agencies to make available as much information as possible. The article mentions several books on open government such as Full Disclosure and Wiki Government.

Visualizing massive amounts of information is an important and challenging task. Pat Hanrahan of Stanford University founded Tableau Software which facilitates information manipulation. Valdis Krebs, a specialist in social interactions was once asked to help speed up a delayed project. He mapped the e-mail conversations between various teams and found out that they all communicated through a single manager. Connecting the teams directly was the key to saving the troubled project.

But large amount of information demand lots of energy. This is why big companies such as Google and Microsoft are building their data centers near hydro generating plants.

What information consumes is rather obvious: it consumes the attention. Hence a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention, said Herbert Simon in 1971.

Weekends in the winter: swimming, ice skating, movies, and reading

Sunday, February 14th, 2010

I would like to describe what I am doing on weekends in Helsinki. Life in a city is certainly different from the life in a smaller town or a countryside. One of the challenges of this life is to do outdoors activities or at least some kind of sports to stay in shape.

This is why I start my weekend from attending a swimming pool, or in fact a Roman bath at Yrjonkatu. The definition of start of the day is quite relative because I am going there typically at 2PM. Earlier during the morning I am reading magazines mostly Communications of ACM or listening to radio. Not so long ago I have discovered Radio Freedom which features prominent journalists such as Vladimir Kara-Murza as well as lots of independent analysts. They often express interesting opinions. One thing that I have noticed is their use of references to literature or books that they have read recently. They are trying to apply the lessons learned from those books to modern life. This definitely characterizes this radio as that of intellectuals.

Anyway, in the swimming pool I am practicing fsreestyle wimming. I am swimming 500-1,000 meters depending on further plans. As of now, I can swim arbitrary long distances but not very fast, pretty much as fast as I could do it in breast stroke. However, the idea of swimming freestyle is to swim faster. But my body is experiencing tough resistance of water I am basically making my way through it. Instead I guess I need to flow through it, integrate with the water. But that takes lots of practice. Anyway, I have bought a 10-time ticket that allows me to get to any swimming pool in Helsinki for 36 Euros.

Then after the swimming pool I spend a few hours reading. For example, last weekend I was reading Economist magazine which I like quite a lot. I have bought another issue because of the funny cover image. There was a special report on social networks. Its main points are:

  • MySpace was most visited social network until last year Facebook attracted more visitors. This is because MySpace was focusing on music and movies, whereas Facebook built a platform for content sharing. As broadband Internet spread through the world people got more interested in their own content.
  • Twitter is very different from other social networks because it is like a broadcasting framework, not content sharing. The latter always assumes a certain degree of privacy, for example only your friends can see your pictures. In Twitter everybody can subscribe to your tweets.
  • So far social networks have been barely profitable because advertisers don’t think that people will click on ads placed on social networks. This is because people are concentrated on their or their friends’ content, not on ads. But the special report argues that people trust their friends’ recommendations most, thus an ad saying that your friend has bought product X will likely influence your decision.
  • Many smaller enterprises are using Twitter to advertise themselves. For example one bakery was tweeting upcoming donut sales and soon got over 50,000 followers. Another example is using Facebook as a game distribution platform. A classical Cafe World game has attracted over 10 million players in just a week. This is because of Facebook’s status updates. When your friend says that (s)he has become a Pizza Tycoon you think you should also become one. The network effect takes over. Gaming industry has never seen such growth rates before.
  • People are increasingly using mobile devices to access social networks. Most of these devices are GPS-enabled. This opens another avenue for advertisers: location-aware ads.

On Sunday I am going to a lake to skate. I am preparing for a ice-skating marathon which will take place in the end of February in Kuopio. It is a funny thing which I will definitely describe in another post if I take part in it. The idea is that you have to skate as much as 200 km! But of course there are smaller distances such as 100km, 50km, 25km, and 12km. I will try to skate 25km. Because I am using traditional skates, not speed-skating type of gear my speed is not that great. A speed skater can maintain a 30km/h speed during the whole 200km race. Last weekend I skated 15km on a lake at Munkkiniemi and my speed was less than 10km/h.

Last but not least, I got used to going to movies. There is a gorgeous movie theater near my home in Tennispalatsi. I have bought a group ticket that gives access to 5 movies, each priced at 8.5 Euros. This is quite a big discount, as a single 3D movie is priced at 13 Euros. So far I have watched Avatar 3D, Up in the Air, and Sherlock Holmes. All are gorgeous movies.